top of page

One More Chance

(all names in this story are edited to protect the privacy of personal data)


It was a chilly November evening when I decided to give John another chance. His indiscretion, a fleeting but painful memory, had left deep scars. He promised change, swore it was a one-time mistake, and with a heavy heart, I forgave him. Love, after all, is about forgiveness, right?

As weeks turned into months, the initial relief of reconciliation gave way to a gnawing suspicion. John was late from work more often than not, his phone always on silent. Every "sorry, I got held up at work" sounded less like truth and more like deceit. I tried to trust him, to believe in his promises, but the unchanged behaviors poked at old wounds.

One evening, over a quiet dinner I'd prepared to try and bridge the growing distance between us, I finally voiced my fears. "John, you said things would be different," I started, my voice shaky. "But nothing's changed. Can you honestly tell me there’s nothing to worry about?"

John looked up from his plate, his fork halfway to his mouth, pausing. "Emily, I'm trying. It's just been really busy at work," he replied, his voice weary.

"But it's more than just being busy, isn't it?" I pressed, needing to hear him say it. "You’re distant, always distracted. It’s like you’re not really here with me."

He sighed, setting his fork down. "I don’t know what you want me to say. I told you I was sorry. I’m here, aren’t I?"

"You are, but it feels like only part of you is," I said, my voice growing stronger with each word. "Being physically present isn't the same as being truly with someone."

Silence fell between us, heavy and uncomfortable. It was broken by John's phone vibrating on the table. Instinctively, he glanced at it, then quickly flipped it face down. My heart sank.

"Are you going to answer that?" I asked, nodding toward his phone.

"It’s just a work email. It can wait," he muttered, but his eagerness to hide the screen spoke volumes.

"John, if we’re going to make this work, there can't be any secrets. Not anymore," I said, my voice pleading for the honesty I so desperately needed from him.

With a reluctant sigh, he picked up the phone, unlocking it and sliding it across the table to me. "Go ahead. You might as well see for yourself."

The email was from a name I didn’t recognize, but the words were clear enough. "Can't wait to see you this weekend." My heart froze. This wasn’t work. This was something else, something more.

I looked up at him, searching his face for any sign of the man I thought I had married. "John, what is this? Is this why nothing has changed?"

He ran his hands through his hair, a gesture of frustration and defeat. "I don’t know what to say, Emily. It’s complicated. I never meant for any of this to happen."

"But it did happen, John. Again," I replied, the reality setting in. I stood up, my chair scraping sharply against the floor. "I can't do this anymore. I gave you a chance to change, to prove that our marriage meant as much to you as it does to me. But I can't keep giving you chances if you're not willing to fight for us."

As I walked away from the table, from John, and from the life we had built together, I felt a mixture of sadness and relief. It was over, but maybe now, I could start to heal.

Did I do the right thing walking away? How many chances do you give someone who keeps making the same mistakes? What would you have done in my shoes?


bottom of page